Public's Reaction
The public reaction has been very negative especially since there other scandals involving amazon such as their treatment of their truck drivers and how they treat small business owners trying to sell on the website. Governmental officials have gotten involved including the two OSHA fines mentioned before. Politicians including Bernie Sanders and Joe Biden have called for better treatment of their workers. Some states have gone as far to pass laws addressing work quotas being used in warehouses. "New York isn’t the first state to take such action against Amazon and its peers for quotas. In September, California signed into law a similar bill. And earlier this year, lawmakers in Washington and New Hampshire introduced bills that target warehouse production quotas." The law passed in New York mandated that employers make the requirements for quotas known to employees. The bill also requires amazon and other companies with warehouses to notify their employees if there is change to expectations. It also prevents companies from imposing quotas that prevent workers from taking breaks.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v3oVbC-Z7HI
There have also been calls for unionization as a way to protect warehouse works
and give them more power to enact change. There were three total votes with one
vote resulting in the creation of a union at the Staten island warehouse in New York.
The leader of the Amazon Labor Union (ALU) is named Chris Smalls who was a
former employee. Push for unionization has been backed by Bernie Sanders and
other progressive lawmakers. Bernie Sanders pushed for the federal government to
cut contracts with amazon stating "[Amazon] has become the poster child for illegal
anti-union behavior while raking billions in federal contracts. The Staten Island
Warehouse remains the only unionized warehouse under amazon despite the
company suing claiming the vote to unionize wasn’t legitimate. On Jan 11, 2023
The National Labor Relations Board ruled that the union had won the election. The
fact that Amazon pushed back against the results of the vote to unionize further
shows how much amazon is focused on maintaining power and prioritizing their
profit over their employees. Since there has been such widespread response by
the government from states working to limit or ban quotas in warehouses as well
as investigations and fines into amazon. By the time the government gets involved
the situation is very bad, this is because governmental action is very slow and
historically reluctant to go after corporations especially one as big as amazon.
The fact that the government not only launched investigations but also issued
fines as well as state governments going after the direct practices of Amazon
means the company won't change their practices unless forced to.
References:
https://www.cnbc.com/2023/01/11/amazon-union-victory-at-new-york-warehouse-upheld-by-
labor-board.htmlhttps://www.cnbc.com/2022/06/03/new-york-passes-bill-targeting-amazon-
warehouse-productivity-quotas.html https://www.politico.com/news/2022/04/26/bernie-pressures-biden-on-amazon-unions-the-time-for-talk-is-over-00027872
It is clear to the public eye that amazon will always prioritize profits over simple human rights and a good ethical code. The company should not have let any issues get this bad with how their employees are treated. I think it will take government interference to make any improvements.
ReplyDeleteYes I agree Amazon won't change by themselves they will have to be forced to.
ReplyDeleteIt was kind of discouraging to see that the union from Staten Island had celebrated a great victory to be the first to unionize. They were the first towards change and more improvements made to their compensation. Afterwards, it was difficulty for them to move forward due to the laws and other getting in their way to make change.
ReplyDeleteYeah I think once they is another union at other Amazon warehouses they will have more power and able to demand accountability from Amazon.
DeleteIt's good to see that governmental officials are getting involved and that some states are passing laws to address these issues. Companies like Amazon need to take responsibility for their actions and prioritize the safety and well being of their workers.
ReplyDeleteIt was encouraging to see that government officials are starting to take action and demand accountability from Amazon. I personally think that the government response is a bit late but that is just how the government works.
Delete